Pirates Cave Chandlery Reviews

Pirates Cave Chandlery has an overall rating of 4.8 based on 99 reviews. Customer feedback on Pirates Cave Chandlery is mixed: Pirates Cave Chandlery reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide selection of products, competitive pricing, fast shipping, and excellent customer service, which strongly appeal to pirate enthusiasts, costume party attendees, and collectors of nautical memorabilia. However, Pirates Cave Chandlery is often criticized for its limited stock on popular items, occasional shipping delays, website navigation issues, and lack of detailed product descriptions.

4.8/5.0

99 reviews

5 Stars

89

4 Stars

8

3 Stars

1

2 Stars

1

1 Star

1

All Pirates Cave Chandlery Reviews (99)
KayleeWade
September 01, 2022
"All Good Things to Say"
I’ve got nothing but good things to say. I placed an order for a macerator over the phone with a deadline that was a bit tight, but they accepted it. Later on, they reached out to suggest a different model that had a more dependable delivery. As the date approached, I opted for that one, and they handled the exchange without charging me extra. They even covered the shipping costs, which was really impressive!
Dannydanyo
June 20, 2022
"Fantastic experience! 👍🏻"
Fantastic experience! This was my first time shopping with Pirates Cave, and I gotta say, I'm quite impressed. The LV showed up super fast and I put it to work right off the bat. It's high quality and fits well, so I'll be using it regularly for the next year. My coworker just grabbed one too, thanks to my suggestion. I won't think twice about shopping at Pirates Cave again. 👍🏻👍🏻
redgoose951
May 30, 2022
"Great Deal!"
Amazing discount on a Henry Lloyd Women's Jacket and quick shipping. I was so impressed that I tried to grab another, but they were all gone!
JulianMartinez
May 06, 2022
"Issues and Outcomes in the End"
Got my order in just 48 hours, but it arrived damaged. I followed their return process, and they received it back in 2 days, but it's been 8 days now and still no refund. Some guy on the phone today told me to hang tight for another 5-7 days for the refund, plus an extra week for the return shipping costs... Only one person I spoke to seemed legit (Ian). I left a negative review, and guess what? I actually got my money back... Crazy, right? Thanks, Nathan!
#Kristine_H
April 05, 2022
"Great service overall"
The service was top-notch, no issues at all, but I really wish the lifejacket hadn't arrived attached to this huge chunk of plastic that I now gotta get rid of.
SaraJones
October 11, 2021
"Consistently Excellent Service"
Always top-notch service from these folks. The team is super helpful and goes above and beyond to assist you.
BeatriceSutton
September 06, 2021
"Top-notch service"
I got two ropes with varying thicknesses and lengths, and I could pick the exact lengths I needed. That was a big reason I went with this company instead of others that only had set lengths. The delivery was super quick. I'm really happy with both the products and the service from this company.
bigleopard783
July 28, 2021
"Parts for Exhaust"
Great site! Quick shipping. The items showed up in good condition, nicely packed. I'm really pleased with the service and will definitely shop here again. Thanks a bunch!
maxkevmurphy
July 09, 2021
"Chandlers got my order to me in 48 hours..."
Chandlers got my order to me in 48 hours, and they were just as described. Plus, I found the best price around for the item!
BrentParker
June 29, 2021
"Awesome experience with these folks!"
I was attracted by their competitive prices right from the start, but I had a question about one product and needed it delivered pretty fast. A single call got my question sorted, and they immediately contacted their supplier to find an item that was out of stock for me. Fantastic, knowledgeable, and personal service - I definitely recommend them.
FernandoFreeman
April 20, 2021
"Awesome experience"
Fantastic service, cost, and shipping—what else can I say but thanks a bunch!
EliFoster
March 11, 2021
"Delivery the next day"
I got a new lifejacket and it showed up the very next day! Awesome service.
BillSullivan
November 04, 2020
"Great experience with my ebike purchase and swift issue handling"
After buying two fantastic ebikes, I ran into some trouble with the batteries. Nathan, the Manager, along with the manufacturers, handled the situation like pros. They sorted everything out quickly and to my complete satisfaction. I'm really impressed with how Pirates Cave runs their business and I can't recommend them enough. I'm one happy customer! Thanks a bunch.
kkpaule26
September 26, 2020
"Got a Sevylor 12V pump"
I got myself a Sevylor 12V pump. It showed up ahead of schedule. I was looking to inflate my Kampa air awning, but I was aware beforehand that the adaptors weren't meant for that, so I tweaked the ones that came with it, and it performed even better than I thought it would.

Super pleased with the delivery and the price from Pirates Cave.
DeannaPatterson
September 14, 2020
"Extremely unsatisfactory experience"
I had a really bad experience with Pirates Cave. I placed my first online order back in March, and after waiting three weeks without any confirmation or updates, I decided to call and check on it. They informed me that my order was being held because some items were out of stock, and they couldn't tell me when they might be available. To make matters worse, the person I spoke to was quite rude, saying, "we're really busy right now, so we can't promise that all orders will be shipped on time!" Three weeks without any word from them, and they didn’t even reach out to see if I wanted the available items sent, to cancel the order, or to wait for the rest. That’s just unacceptable!

I tried to give them another chance, considering the stock issues due to Covid, and placed a second order with just two items. Guess what? They sent me the wrong items! After some back and forth, I finally got one correct item, but the second one was still unavailable. Over a week went by with no updates or refund. When I called again, it turned out my refund had been missed! The service is really lacking. I bet picking things up in person is fine, but ordering online and waiting for delivery is just not worth the trouble.

View More Reviews

Have a question about Pirates Cave Chandlery?

Customer Reviews

Ask a Question

Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.